Liar Liar Pants on Fire: Why Kids Lie and What Parents Can Do About It

Liar Liar Pants on Fire: Why Kids Lie and What Parents Can Do About It

Why do children lie and how should parents respond when they do?

In this episode of The Guiding Parent Podcast, Tammy and Shannon explore the developmental reasons behind childhood lying, from imaginative storytelling and testing boundaries to avoiding trouble or disappointment.

Discover practical, age-appropriate strategies to encourage honesty without shame or punishment, model truthful behaviour, and create a safe, trusting environment where children feel comfortable admitting mistakes and telling the truth.

Highlights:

Avoid setting children up to lie, provide age-appropriate guidance, and focus on correcting mistakes rather than assigning blame. Allow natural consequences, support children in rebuilding trust, and avoid labelling them as liars.

  • Why Children Lie: Understanding the Developmental Reasons
  • Understanding the Why behind the Lie: What is the need to lie communicating
  • Creating a Safe Environment That Encourages Honesty
  • Modelling Honesty and Building Trust Through Everyday Parenting
  • Practical Strategies for Responding to Lies Without Punishment

We’d love to hear from you! Submit your parenting questions to info@theguidingmindset.com and we’ll share our perspective in an upcoming episode.

Don’t forget to check out our GIFT VAULT - updated weekly for more gifts on this podcast and other podcasts in our network.

https://network.inspiredspeakernetwork.com/vault

About the Hosts:

In addition to being Mom to four kids in a blended family and a “Gammy,” Tammy Ulrich, MA has always been passionate about making a difference for children and families. For more than 40 years, it has been her life's work—as founder and administrator of a Montessori preschool for 24 years, a college instructor in Child & Family Studies, and now through The Guiding Mindset. Tammy helps parents truly see and understand the unique little human before them. Through practical principles and tools, she supports parents as they nurture and guide their child while navigating their parenting journey with greater confidence and ease.

Shannon Achilles is Tammy’s daughter and the original guinea pig for the Guiding Mindset. Shannon’s a working mom with an exciting job as a grant analyst and is a 20+ year military spouse. She is attempting to train for a sprint triathlon, loves reading and building LEGOs.

Shannon is parenting her own son with the Guiding Mindset framework. She is well versed in the challenges facing parents in our ever-changing world. Shannon is excited to share The Guiding Mindset with other parents and families so we can all add more ease and joy to the adventure that is parenthood.

Connect with Tammy & Shannon:

Website: www.theguidingmindset.com

Linktree (has links to everything): https://linktr.ee/TheGuidingMindset

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheGuidingMindset/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theguidingmindset

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/tammy-ulrich-43604028/

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgVeKtu-X37BwzRqSzaSTxg

Our gift for you: As parents it seems there is always a reason we need to say “No!” But saying “Yes” eliminates the need for kids to push back. It’s hard to argue with yes!

Claim your gift: https://theguidingmindset.com/power_of_yes__download-501714

The Guiding Parent Podcast is proud to be on the Inspired Speaker Network.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Don’t forget to follow, rate & review. It helps us reach more people who want to create positive change in the world, like you.

Check out More Shows from the Network at https://inspiredspeakernetwork.com

Speaker:

Welcome to the Guiding Parent podcast, where you'll find the mindset and tools to parent

Speaker:

with greater confidence, clarity, and purpose, even when there aren't any easy answers.

Speaker:

Together, we're going to explore how to better nurture and guide our children to support who

Speaker:

they are and who they're becoming so that they can fulfill their unique potential and pride

Speaker:

in our ever-changing world. I'm Tammy Ulrich, your host, parenting and early childhood educator,

Speaker:

mom, and most fun, Tammy. And I'm Shannon, your co-host. I'm Tammy's daughter and mom

Speaker:

to a very energetic little dude called H. We're glad you're here. Let's get started.

Speaker:

At the end of our last podcast, we invited our listeners to send us any questions that they may

Speaker:

have. And so we are going to devote this pod to a question around lying. And so our email says,

Speaker:

my three-year-old is constantly lying. He told me a whole story about another child at preschool

Speaker:

sharing his snack with him that turned out to not be true. If I ask him if he's done something he's

Speaker:

supposed to, like wash his hands or brush his teeth, he will say he did, even though he

Speaker:

didn't. And if he did something wrong, he completely denies it. How do I make him

Speaker:

tell the truth? I'm worried he's becoming a compulsive liar. Well, you know, three-year-olds

Speaker:

can be quite the storytellers and they do tell lies, you know, but it's really quite different

Speaker:

than how we think about lies as adults. You know, developmentally, you know, it's to be expected

Speaker:

that you're going to get some little lies. But those early lies, you know, the brain development

Speaker:

really isn't there for those intentional planned out kind of lies that we really think about

Speaker:

in somebody who's a liar. It takes cognitive skills that just aren't there yet. So you really

Speaker:

want to be conscious about thinking of it as lying in the adult sense. You know, at this age,

Speaker:

you know, it just isn't that calculated deception. It's not malicious, you know, it's not manipulative.

Speaker:

It takes kids developing a perspective taking or having that understanding that someone else can

Speaker:

know and think things differently than they do. You know, they're still kind of in their own little

Speaker:

world, egocentric. So, you know, as those things develop, they can become better and more

Speaker:

intentional with their little mistruths. So really what it boils down to is we really need to consider

Speaker:

what is behind the lie. So let's look at why do kids lie. But before we go there,

Speaker:

Shannon, why do you lie? I would never. You weren't quite the little liar as a little person.

Speaker:

It was. Our last pod could be devoted to my kid. This one might have been devoted to little me.

Speaker:

But, you know, I think as an adult, when I lie, it's definitely things, you know, like telling

Speaker:

someone that I'm unavailable for an event because I don't want to go, not, you know, that I don't

Speaker:

want to go, you know, saying, Oh, yeah, I just can't make it rather than, you know, out and out,

Speaker:

just being like, No, not interested. Or, you know, a situation of like telling someone, you know,

Speaker:

a little white lie, you know, you're trying to not hurt someone's feelings or, you know,

Speaker:

kind of smooth a situation. And so I think as an adult, those are the kinds of lies that, you know,

Speaker:

I tell, I feel like those are, you know, kind of common adult lies, maybe, you know, as a

Speaker:

parent, something about the park being closed on Tuesdays, you know, these kinds of things.

Speaker:

And so, you know, I think the overarching kind of overlap that we see in these kinds of, you know,

Speaker:

deceptions or mistruths or lies or whatever, it's kind of like the sense of self preservation of

Speaker:

not wanting to look bad, not wanting to upset someone, you know, you're trying to work around

Speaker:

that. And so, you know, I think it's important to kind of acknowledge that, you know, if an

Speaker:

adult is lying out of these reasons, it's very similar to why kids lie, you know, it's the same

Speaker:

kind of thing, not wanting to get in trouble, not wanting some, you know, someone to be mad at you.

Speaker:

And so, you know, looking at the things that our kids do are very similar to the things that we

Speaker:

do as adults. Right. And so, you know, we need to have that in mind that, you know, we don't

Speaker:

want to be thinking of our child in this terrible negative terms when it's something that's

Speaker:

kind of human, you know, that little lies happen. So, you know, like you said, the main things

Speaker:

being self-preservation, we don't want to get in trouble or disappoint, you know, disappoint

Speaker:

someone, disappoint our parent. I think for our little three-year-old, you know, doing something

Speaker:

wrong and denying it, that's probably exactly what it boils down to is that they don't want

Speaker:

to get in trouble or they don't want, you know, they don't want mom to be mad or they don't want

Speaker:

to, you know, they don't want to be in trouble for some reason. Another reason, though, that

Speaker:

little ones lie is that they want it to be true. You know, like I said, they're storytellers.

Speaker:

They may genuinely blur that line between what's true and what they wish to be true.

Speaker:

You know, they can, they have big imaginations and sometimes there's, you know, this line between

Speaker:

what's real and pretend is a little shaky. And so, you know, to them, this big story they

Speaker:

imagined might feel, might feel very real. They're also little scientists. So, you know,

Speaker:

they're experimenting with words and impact and the results, you know, what happens when

Speaker:

I say certain things. So there's this sense of cause and effect. Words have power and,

Speaker:

you know, how do I use words and can I use words to get away with something or, you know,

Speaker:

can I, how can I, how can I, you know, experiment with this to see, to see what will happen?

Speaker:

It makes me think about when your little brother was at Child's View and there was a child in the,

Speaker:

in the classroom that was known for, I can't remember what it was that, that he was doing,

Speaker:

but it, you know, he was, he did it pretty consistently and it was a big deal and

Speaker:

everybody was upset by it. So one day your brother actually did that thing that this

Speaker:

kid had been, had been doing and then kind of stood back and watched. And sure enough,

Speaker:

you know, there was the uproar, there was the upset. This kid got in trouble until one of

Speaker:

the other kids said, he didn't do it. Justin did. And so then it was like, oh, no, Justin's

Speaker:

lying and saying, you know, trying to, trying to trick, trick us into thinking that this kid,

Speaker:

and really what it boiled down to is he just wanted to understand these dynamics. He was

Speaker:

experimenting. So, you know, sometimes it's, it's about just figuring out how words work

Speaker:

and figuring out how reactions work in connection with, connection with words.

Speaker:

Absolutely. And, you know, I feel like when Henry was small, we would see it a lot of, you know,

Speaker:

him doing something and then being like, Oh no, I didn't do it. Or it was an accident.

Speaker:

It was his favorite. It was an accident and like very clearly things that were not accidents. Like,

Speaker:

why are you effectively lying and telling me something was an accident when you very clearly

Speaker:

did it on purpose. But for him, the accident was the outcome. Like, yes, he did something with,

Speaker:

you know, whatever intent or, you know, but he didn't expect it to turn out that way.

Speaker:

And that was the accident. And so I think we can also be aware of, you know, those kinds of little

Speaker:

things your kid might say like, Oh, I didn't mean to. And you're like, yeah,

Speaker:

you very clearly did. But the final, you know, consequence of whatever happened,

Speaker:

maybe what was unintentional and accidental. And I know, like, when another fun story about my

Speaker:

little brother is, you know, he used to climb into our pantry and eat like literal spoonfuls of sugar.

Speaker:

And yeah, same kind of thing. Like, you know, he just didn't have the impulse control to not do

Speaker:

this. Like, he probably knew darn good and well that it wasn't something he was supposed to be

Speaker:

doing. Oh, he knew. But still, but the sugar was calling him. Right. And so, you know, sometimes

Speaker:

when our kiddos are, you know, lying, or, you know, saying things are accidental, say they

Speaker:

mean to do something, it can really be just because they can't literally can't stop themselves,

Speaker:

you know, they haven't reached a point where they have true impulse control. And, you know, I think

Speaker:

at that point, it's important for us as parents to recognize, you know, where we need to step in

Speaker:

as well to just prevent these sort of situations from happening in the first place.

Speaker:

Yeah, sometimes, I mean, we'll get to that. But sometimes just part of that, if we know our

Speaker:

child doesn't have the impulse control, then we need, you know, in the case with Justin,

Speaker:

then, you know, we ended up putting the sugar up, but we actually ended up locking the pantry

Speaker:

door. You know, so another thing that happens with kids is that they get embarrassed. You

Speaker:

know, or we ask them something and they don't tell the truth because they're embarrassed or they

Speaker:

feel ashamed. This is especially true as kids start to get a little bit older, you know,

Speaker:

kindergarten, elementary may start to feel this way. So we want to be aware that they might be

Speaker:

just, you know, trying to save face, trying not to look bad. So, you know, shame or embarrassment

Speaker:

can kind of kind of come into play with that as well. Yes, you know, talking about kids as they

Speaker:

get older. I think another thing we see is, you know, are we starting to lie to protect a

Speaker:

friend or, you know, that kind of behavior? You know, like you were saying elementary age kids,

Speaker:

I know, like the kind of kindergarten, like five year old crowd, those guys are good at

Speaker:

tattletailing. Yes. They're the little police. Yeah. But, you know, once you're past kind of

Speaker:

that stage of, you know, wanting to be up in everybody's business and make sure, you know,

Speaker:

it's a sense of justice. It's an important stage of development. But, you know, once they get

Speaker:

beyond kind of that, then you do see stuff like lying to protect friends, lying to,

Speaker:

yeah, with a sense of other people in mind. So one of the most important things that we can do

Speaker:

to help our kids and prevent lying is create and, you know, what's our environment set up

Speaker:

like to prevent that? You know, like, for instance, the story with Justin and the sugar,

Speaker:

you know, we had to lock the pantry, we put it away. So he couldn't go do that

Speaker:

because he just couldn't stop himself. And we really want to remember that like everything else,

Speaker:

it's a process. It's development. So, you know, what our expectations are about our kids and why

Speaker:

they do what they do. Development always comes into play with that. And, you know, how we handle

Speaker:

these little mistruths are going to impact, you know, future ways of how they, you know,

Speaker:

express themselves, honestly, or not. But it also really impacts our connection with our kids.

Speaker:

So we want to make sure that we're creating an environment and an atmosphere where

Speaker:

that connection doesn't get harmed by, you know, when these kinds of things happen.

Speaker:

So the main thing is, you know, we don't want to punish them for telling the truth.

Speaker:

We want to make sure that, you know, we're putting the emphasis on telling the truth,

Speaker:

but when mistruths happen, that it doesn't become, you know, this big thing.

Speaker:

This is one of my favorite little Henry stories around, you know, being honest. When he was

Speaker:

really little, he had to have been like three, maybe four. And it was Christmas time. And so he,

Speaker:

you know, in our house, we have a rule that we don't have food in our bedrooms.

Speaker:

And he got busted at quiet time with candy cane. And so, you know, but you know better. We don't

Speaker:

have food in our bedroom. I'm going to take that downstairs. You can have it after dinner.

Speaker:

And this little voice, do I have to give you both of them?

Speaker:

And so he did. He added himself that he had another one. And it could have been, you know,

Speaker:

a whole nother lecture of, you know, I had already told you that you couldn't have one.

Speaker:

Of course, you can't have two, you know, this big, huge thing. But, you know, he told the truth.

Speaker:

And so, you know, rather than have it be, you know, a further situation of him, you know,

Speaker:

getting in trouble, he didn't really get in trouble. But, you know, to make it into a

Speaker:

bigger thing that it needed to be, you know, just like, nope, but both of them got to go downstairs

Speaker:

and leave it at that. Yeah. And sometimes we can even thank them for, you know, telling the truth.

Speaker:

Thank you for letting me know, you know, or thank you for, you know, bringing that one up too,

Speaker:

so that we're acknowledging, you know, when those, that that is when those positive,

Speaker:

positive truths are happening. Right. And other reinforcement and all that stuff.

Speaker:

Another thing that creates a difference for us is when it's just a normal part of life

Speaker:

that we're really listening to our kids and that they know that they can talk to us about anything,

Speaker:

that they can come to us about things that they're uncomfortable about or that they're

Speaker:

scared about or when they, you know, something didn't go right, they made a big mistake.

Speaker:

That makes me think about little Shannon when she was told to go into her room to clean up and

Speaker:

instead she and her friend piled everything right into the middle of her room, emptied all the

Speaker:

drawer. I mean, it was a big, huge mess. And she came out, mama, it's too big. And, you know,

Speaker:

it could have been a much bigger problem if we'd have looked at it

Speaker:

in that way. But she knew she could come and talk, you know, say, I made this mistake. I need help.

Speaker:

And so we want to create that sense of openness that it's okay to make mistakes and you can come

Speaker:

and tell and you're not going to get in trouble because you made this mistake

Speaker:

so that we have that sense of openness. We will definitely want to do that when the

Speaker:

mistakes are small so that when they get big, you know, think teenagers,

Speaker:

they'll still come to you because those mistakes are going to need you too.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think that there's some adage that I've heard about, you know, little people make little

Speaker:

mistakes. And, you know, if you want to create systems and, you know, a sense of family, you

Speaker:

know, culture of how we deal with that when they're small and their mistakes are small.

Speaker:

So that, yeah, like you said, when they're big and their mistakes are bigger,

Speaker:

you've already established like, oh, when, you know, whatever hits the fan, I go to mom

Speaker:

or I go to dad. And I know that, you know, that's a safe, a safe way to deal with things.

Speaker:

Right. Yeah, absolutely. Making it safe to make mistakes. And when they do come to us

Speaker:

with these things, we want to be sure we're not teasing them or embarrassing them or asking

Speaker:

questions that, you know, that are going to be embarrassing that they might not want to admit to.

Speaker:

So let it, you know, help draw it out from them, but not in a way that makes them feel, you know,

Speaker:

embarrassed because then they're going to be less likely to tell us things.

Speaker:

Right. And even, you know, I think it can really vary based on a kid and your family culture of,

Speaker:

you know, what crosses that line and from, you know, kind of fun, you know, teasing ha ha to

Speaker:

like feeling teased in that negative sense. And like, you know, part of what makes it so that

Speaker:

your kid can come and talk to you is if that sense of feeling safe and if they're, you know,

Speaker:

feeling like they're just going to get made fun of, that it's not safe. And, you know,

Speaker:

it absolutely hinders connection. And yeah, if you're not a safe place for them,

Speaker:

they're not going to come tell you. And I like to joke, you know, especially when H was smaller,

Speaker:

like, I swear he would tell me like literally everything that, you know, crossed his little

Speaker:

brain. And, you know, as he's gotten a little bit older, that's less, you know,

Speaker:

like that I get the literal complete brain dump. But he still does come and talk to me about a lot

Speaker:

of different random things. And so part of being that safe place for him, I feel like, is being

Speaker:

available and making sure that, you know, if he wants to talk to me about something, you know,

Speaker:

put my phone down and really focus and pay attention to whatever he's saying,

Speaker:

so that we do, you know, continue to create that sense of, you know, connection and safety.

Speaker:

Connection is just so big. It's such an important piece. And when our kids feel that connection,

Speaker:

we maintain that connection. There's so much more willing to come to us and be honest and say what's,

Speaker:

you know, talk about what's going on for them. And so we just want to make that just a part of

Speaker:

life is that we just talk that we're, you know, you're the safe place that they can come to with

Speaker:

whatever it is. Another thing we can do, especially like with littles that are still

Speaker:

kind of figuring out that real versus pretend, you know, their big imaginations is asking them,

Speaker:

you know, like, what part of that story was real? What part of that is, is pretend and starting to,

Speaker:

you know, or what else happened? Or what, you know, what do you think really happened there?

Speaker:

Is that the whole story? Asking some, some guiding questions or leading questions to kind of

Speaker:

draw out for them so that they can start to see what part was, what part was real and what

Speaker:

wasn't. And I think that's kind of the case for our, for our listener, with the story from,

Speaker:

you know, that the friend shared, shared lunch, or shared their snack. You know,

Speaker:

is that it was, that's what, you know, that's, that's what perhaps he had hoped would happen.

Speaker:

And so that was his own, you know, so could just ask some more questions about it and not,

Speaker:

you know, what part's real, what part, you know, what part isn't. Another piece to that,

Speaker:

though, is especially for really, really young children, we want to kind of be aware of engaging

Speaker:

in stories and talking about things, you know, because they're still trying to differentiate

Speaker:

between what's real and what's not. And so giving them books and stories and stuff that are real,

Speaker:

that are, are about real things so that they start to have that, you know, we can have more of

Speaker:

that fantasy as they get a little bit older and that distinction is clearer. But things like

Speaker:

talking animals and so forth, not to, not to say not to have any of that, but, but

Speaker:

might then still ask questions when we have a story that is very much around pretend. What part

Speaker:

of that was true? Do animals really talk? What kind of a habitat does an animal really live?

Speaker:

Do they live in a house? You know, so that kids start to see that difference between real and

Speaker:

pretend. Yeah. And I think, you know, especially if you're thinking about little kids and we can

Speaker:

start to think about, you know, where would we want to start? And so part of that, you know,

Speaker:

from the time that they're very small is modeling honesty. And, you know, if you're little ones,

Speaker:

and I mean, of course, older children too, but if from, you know, the whole history of their

Speaker:

little life, they've seen their parents lying, you know, or being lied to. Yeah.

Speaker:

Like telling them the park is closed on Tuesday.

Speaker:

Right. But I mean, we joke, but like, literally, like if they see that consistently, like you can

Speaker:

say, you know, lying's not okay all you want, but if they're watching your behavior and, you know,

Speaker:

do as I say, not as I do, never work. But, you know, and like we joke in our house,

Speaker:

like sometimes like it'll be like, Oh, the ice cream's gone. And my husband will be like,

Speaker:

Henry ate all the ice cream and Henry knows darn good. Well, he didn't eat the last of the ice cream,

Speaker:

but my husband did. And so, you know, we can obviously like, you know, I still have a family

Speaker:

culture that teases and, you know, but once our kids are old enough that they really have that

Speaker:

sense of what's, you know, joking versus what's an actual, you know, deception or lie.

Speaker:

Yeah. So we really do want to model being honest, you know, when you call your boss to say you're

Speaker:

sick, don't do it in front of your kid. Don't lie to them, even about the simple things,

Speaker:

you know, even those things that, you know, we're out of, we're out of ice cream when

Speaker:

or the park closed. Yeah. So they really see that honesty is part of your family values that

Speaker:

that it really is something you're, you're showing and you're making a, you're making a point

Speaker:

of being honest. So that that's just part of family culture, part of our part of our

Speaker:

values. And we can also make it part of conversations when mistruths come in there,

Speaker:

you know, that it's important. I can trust your words. You know, that's something that we can

Speaker:

say, you know, is that really the truth? Because I really need to be able to trust your words.

Speaker:

Yeah. And you're talking about family culture. I feel like that's a really important

Speaker:

thing to emphasize, you know, if we're, you know, I need to be able to trust you,

Speaker:

I need to be able to, to believe what you're telling me. And, you know,

Speaker:

part of parenting, I feel like is dealing with like the consequences when things go awry. And so,

Speaker:

you know, it's really, really easy in that instance. Like, if you don't tell me the truth,

Speaker:

I can't, you know, the consequence of that is I can't trust what you're saying.

Speaker:

You wouldn't know anything about that, would you, Shannon?

Speaker:

Of course not.

Speaker:

Oh, you have those conversations just to be able to trust your words.

Speaker:

Well, and, you know, now that, you know, I'm parenting, it's generational. And sometimes

Speaker:

the words that come out of my mouth sound shockingly like yours. And that is definitely

Speaker:

one of them. You know, I literally feel like I'm parroting you sometimes when I'm like,

Speaker:

dude, if I can't trust you, you know, the consequence of that is, I don't know,

Speaker:

you know, what's believable. And, you know, that's going to impact what you, you know,

Speaker:

what you get to do. Right. So, so it's really a natural consequence. We don't need to create,

Speaker:

you know, these punishments. It's just part of how life will go. If I can't, if I can't trust your

Speaker:

words, then that's the natural consequences. We may not be able to do certain things or

Speaker:

I'm going to need to check up on that. Or, you know, you may not have as much freedom.

Speaker:

So it just kind of naturally, you know, naturally takes care of itself.

Speaker:

But another, another piece to all of this is not setting our kids up to lie. You know,

Speaker:

like a child comes to us with chocolate all over their face and we say, did you eat the chocolate

Speaker:

bar? Well, it's obviously the chocolate bar. So, you know, when they say, no, I didn't do it.

Speaker:

Yeah, just completely skip that whole thing. Yeah, dude, you ate chocolate. You know,

Speaker:

it's not time to eat chocolate. Don't even set them up where they are trying to.

Speaker:

You know, asking that question just puts them on the spot and they're like, oh my gosh,

Speaker:

you know, and, and it's kind of like deer in the headlights because you've probably

Speaker:

asked it in a pretty, you know, you're in trouble way.

Speaker:

You're in. Yeah. So, you know, also want to be aware who you're asking in front of

Speaker:

any kind of question about, you know, what they're, they're doing. And will they be

Speaker:

embarrassed to answer the truth, answer truthfully? Yeah. Also, I think the time and place kind of

Speaker:

stuff, you know, if you're in a situation where, you know, your child is obviously dysregulated

Speaker:

or, you know, they're in front of friends or, you know, there's all sorts of different things

Speaker:

that can influence a child, you know, again, self preservation, trying to save face. And so,

Speaker:

you're going to get a lie rather than the truth. Whereas if you wait until they're,

Speaker:

you know, calm, regulated, and it's just the two of you, you're more likely, I feel like,

Speaker:

to get an honest answer. And your energy, you know, in that moment, you know, if you've calmed down

Speaker:

also and you feel safe now, you know, because, you know, you're in maybe, you know, you're

Speaker:

snuggling on the couch or the atmosphere is just calmer and safer, you're more likely to get.

Speaker:

So, be aware of, you know, be aware of your energy when you have these conversations and that

Speaker:

it feels like, it feels like you're open to them rather than you're ready to judge or,

Speaker:

you know, they're going to get in trouble. Yeah, another like weird one that I see,

Speaker:

you know, with Henry's friends is, you know, parents creating scenarios where

Speaker:

a child is sort of like over protected to the point where they feel like they have to

Speaker:

be deceptive or to lie. I know one of Henry's friends, like, we went fishing and he cut his

Speaker:

finger on his fish hook. So, you know, it wasn't just like a scratch, not deep or anything

Speaker:

serious. And I tried to give him a band-aid and he was like, nope, I don't need a band-aid.

Speaker:

My mom sees a band-aid on my finger, I won't get to go fishing. And like he just said it very

Speaker:

matter-of-factly, like this was, you know, pretty standard that, you know, if an activity results

Speaker:

in, you know, even a scratch, he doesn't get to do it anymore. And so, just being mindful of,

Speaker:

you know, obviously kids need boundaries. We, you know, we're absolutely not saying to let them,

Speaker:

you know, run wild and free. But, you know, being aware of how restrictive those boundaries

Speaker:

are and if they're still age-appropriate, if they need to be loosened a little bit.

Speaker:

Because otherwise you will create a scenario where your kid, you know,

Speaker:

wants to do XYZ and so they just do it anyways. Right. Yeah. And if we're too overly about it,

Speaker:

then, you know, they're likely to lie about it because, you know, they know they can do it.

Speaker:

And they're, you know, they're trying to assert that autonomy and that sense of,

Speaker:

we had a whole podcast on safe risk. You know, they're trying to try to figure out their skills.

Speaker:

They're trying to figure out their bodies and all of that. And if we're pushing back too much on that

Speaker:

and that natural need to, you know, to experience and to do and try things, you know, then it's

Speaker:

kind of setting them up for, you know, for having to go behind their backs to do what they

Speaker:

developmentally need to do. Yeah. And speaking of developmentally, you know, I think that there's

Speaker:

a lot of different ways to address lying with kids and that is very much based on where they are

Speaker:

developmentally. And like you were saying at the beginning, you know, a three-year-old can't lie

Speaker:

with intent. They can't lie with malice. They're just not, you know, at a point developmentally

Speaker:

where that's even possible. Whereas, you know, a 10-year-old can't 100% you know, lie with intent.

Speaker:

And so, you know, how would we handle that? Maybe like our example at the beginning, you know,

Speaker:

from our listener of a child, you know, who says they washed their hands when they didn't.

Speaker:

That's the best way to handle that. Well, I think the first thing to do is don't ask,

Speaker:

did you, did you brush your teeth or did you wash your hands? If you know they didn't,

Speaker:

that's first because then you're setting them up to lie. But, you know, we kind of also just want

Speaker:

to feel like we need to change our focus. That rather than focusing on the fact that they didn't

Speaker:

do what they were supposed to or they said they did when they didn't, how can I successfully

Speaker:

set them up to do what they need to do? And be honest about it or if they're not,

Speaker:

if they just really don't want to do it, okay, they need to be able to say, I don't want to.

Speaker:

That doesn't mean they don't get to. But they can still, and then we can look at, okay,

Speaker:

how can I support them to be able to do what they need to do? So take hand washing, okay,

Speaker:

you know, especially, I feel like I'm being gender here, but I feel like especially boys,

Speaker:

I don't want to go wash their hands. So maybe some cool soap, you know, to encourage it,

Speaker:

the squirt soap or something that gives it some interest, something, so there's little things

Speaker:

we can do that can help support them in being successful in doing the things that we want to,

Speaker:

you know, that we want them to do so that we don't even have to lie about it in the first place,

Speaker:

they don't have to lie about it in the first place that we're supporting them to do what needs to,

Speaker:

what needs to be done. Yeah, we talk a lot about, you know, preparing our environment. And so I think

Speaker:

that's definitely a part of it is, you know, or if you have a child that you know, is going to

Speaker:

say that they brushed their teeth when they didn't, and they're still, you know, a little

Speaker:

guy or a little gal, maybe they need you standing there in the bathroom door frame,

Speaker:

a little more supervision, right? Right. And you know, or let's do it together.

Speaker:

You know, sometimes it's just as simple as, you know, those teeth didn't get brushed,

Speaker:

grab them by the hand, let's go back in and do it together and take them just taking them back.

Speaker:

Or, you know, I've heard you say to to Henry, if I go touch your toothbrush, is it going to

Speaker:

be wet? Yeah, I mean, even now, he'll be like, Oh, yeah, I totally brushed my teeth. And I'm like,

Speaker:

did you I didn't hear this thing? Like, if I go check, he's like, Oh, fine.

Speaker:

So it's back to supporting them and going and doing what they need to do rather than focusing

Speaker:

on the fact that they didn't or the fact that they lied about it, but just let's get to where

Speaker:

we need to go rather than create this need for problems and punishments and so forth.

Speaker:

So again, you know, creating an environment that just helps helps prevent prevent it.

Speaker:

In spite of everything we do, there are still going to be those times,

Speaker:

kids are going to make mistakes, they're going to be afraid of disappointing you

Speaker:

and lies happen. You know, they happen for us as adults, too. But one of the, you know,

Speaker:

one thing we had in in our family is kind of like, if you lie, there's kind of like

Speaker:

consequences and that there was a punishment. So there are the consequences, you've got to deal

Speaker:

with what what's going on here. So, you know, it might be you have to fix the mistake of whatever

Speaker:

problem happened. Plus, now we're talking about rebuilding trust. Now, you know, you may not

Speaker:

get to do XYZ on your own again, because I can't trust that you will do what you say you will do.

Speaker:

So there's kind of this double, you know, double consequence that happens.

Speaker:

Yeah, I know, like, for Henry, he's got boundaries in our neighborhood of where he's allowed

Speaker:

to cruise at will. And so we've had, you know, it happened once where he went beyond that,

Speaker:

and, you know, was dishonest about it. And so then it becomes so okay, I can't trust that

Speaker:

you're going to be where you're supposed to be, because you lied to me about it.

Speaker:

So now your boundaries are not as expansive as they could be, like, you don't get to go outside

Speaker:

without supervision. And obviously, he's old enough that that's okay now. But, you know,

Speaker:

if you're gonna lie to me about where you are, I can't let you go, you know, wander the neighborhood.

Speaker:

You have to, you know, be supervised. And so the consequence, you know, naturally,

Speaker:

is just that he loses a sense of freedom that he would have had. And, you know, over time,

Speaker:

obviously, you know, we worked that back out. And, you know, now he's really good about calling me

Speaker:

and being like, you know, I went across the street, which means you can go across the street to where

Speaker:

the track is and play on the soccer field. But that has to be a conversation every time because

Speaker:

it's a little bit farther from our house. And you you have the luxury of having a little

Speaker:

tracker on him in a neighborhood that is maintained. Yeah, we have a really safe

Speaker:

neighborhood. And yeah, he's got a watch. So I know where he is.

Speaker:

I think another thing that's really important is to think about how we're framing things. And when

Speaker:

we're talking to our kids, how we're framing those times when they're telling a lie,

Speaker:

please, please don't call your child a liar. You know, a liar is someone who consistently lies

Speaker:

for the purpose of deceiving people for their own benefit. You know, it's malicious and

Speaker:

manipulative. It's really has, to me, very negative connotations. And I think calling,

Speaker:

you know, calling that our child that is big. It's just it's not a label that we want to attach.

Speaker:

I mean, that's something that's going to hurt their little spirits. And it's not, you know,

Speaker:

when kids, kids tend to fall into our our labels and our expectations. So if that's our focus,

Speaker:

and we don't want to create a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Speaker:

Exactly. So, you know, let's not let's not even think of them that way. Instead, just looking at

Speaker:

at supporting them and telling, you know, at finding the truth and expressing that instead.

Speaker:

Yeah, that's an important distinction.

Speaker:

Right. Yeah, I mean, we can just say I know I know that isn't true. So let's talk about

Speaker:

what really happened. We can also, you know, think about as we think about that they're not

Speaker:

really, you know, they're not really lying, not true liars, you know, we really can think about

Speaker:

doing all of these different things we're talking about so that it helps prevent that from happening

Speaker:

from them becoming that, you know, so between not attaching that label and providing the support,

Speaker:

you know, that makes a huge, a huge difference. We're looking at fixing mistakes instead of

Speaker:

punishing them.

Speaker:

Well, yeah, and, you know, one of the big tenets of the guiding mindset philosophy is, you know,

Speaker:

the very first principle is it starts with you. And so, you know, I think, you know, if we're

Speaker:

talking about what really prevents lying, it's definitely worth taking a minute to kind of turn

Speaker:

into inward and look at yourself and, you know, like we said, like lying is usually a form of

Speaker:

self-preservation, it's fully fulfilling a need. And so, you know, as parents, are we doing

Speaker:

anything that's contributing to that?

Speaker:

Yeah, it's a way of communicating and, you know, all behavior is communication.

Speaker:

You tell me this all the time.

Speaker:

Another principle is behavior is communication. So, you know, we want to ask ourselves, why

Speaker:

are they lying? What is this telling me? You know, what is this behavior communicating?

Speaker:

You know, so we want to get to, we want to first get to the truth of that. What need is being

Speaker:

met by lying? You know, again, self-preservation is nine times out of ten. But again, it's a

Speaker:

communication. So, we want to look beneath the surface. And we really need to ask ourselves,

Speaker:

why this is happening? What is the reason behind it? Why can't they tell me the truth?

Speaker:

And we need that answer before we look at, okay, what are we going to do about it?

Speaker:

You know, because the reason behind it is really going to tell us how we need to proceed.

Speaker:

You know, with supports or encouragement or redirections, you know, whatever the guidance

Speaker:

might be. Well, as we come to an end, we have three tips for you in terms of handling these

Speaker:

mistruths with our little ones. So, number one, be aware of what you're modeling. You know,

Speaker:

be careful about those little white lies that we tell, you know, we tend to tell our kids or,

Speaker:

you know, your child witnessing the lie you just told your friend, your friend or your boss.

Speaker:

So, you know, again, making sure that you're modeling honesty and creating that as a family,

Speaker:

a family value. The second one is, like I just said, looking beneath the lie to discover

Speaker:

why the lie, you know, they don't want to disappoint you. They just want it to be true.

Speaker:

They're telling a story, you know, those great imaginations, fear of getting in trouble,

Speaker:

you know, seeing what will happen. And then once you understand that, then we can help come to the

Speaker:

come to the truth and know how to how to handle it. And then third, making it safe,

Speaker:

you know, talking and listening is just a part of life, making sure that that they are comfortable

Speaker:

being able to talk about fears, talk about mistakes, you know, those little uncomfortable

Speaker:

things and not punishing the truth when they do instead helping or supporting them in fixing

Speaker:

any kind of problem or mistake. For our try this, you know, we kind of talked about this a little

Speaker:

bit, but, you know, actually really taking, you know, the time to implement it in your parenting

Speaker:

to making sure that, you know, when you see your kid doing something that you know,

Speaker:

they could easily lie about not asking it as a question, you know, don't set them up.

Speaker:

You know, you've clearly got chocolate all over your face. I know you've had ice cream.

Speaker:

So let's deal with, you know, having a treat when we're not supposed to rather than setting them up

Speaker:

to kind of double dip into into trouble and and have to lie about it. And then just being aware

Speaker:

that, you know, some of these things really are things that we can as parents prevent from

Speaker:

happening in the first place. You know, does the ice cream need to be accessible

Speaker:

in the first place to get it, you know, is there a way to make it so that these things

Speaker:

for a little people that don't have a lot of impulse control can just, you know,

Speaker:

not even have it be an issue in the first place. And then, you know, as another try this,

Speaker:

you too can send us questions. So try this and send us one of yours. Until next time.